Lesson 1: Origins of American Political Thought and the Roots of Revolution
American political ideas about liberty and self-government did not appear fully formed at the moment the colonists declared independence from Britain.
The varied strands that became the American republic had many roots reaching far back in time and across the Atlantic to Europe, and it was old ideas rather than new ones that led the colonists to revolt and form a new nation.
John Locke, a seventeenth-century English philosopher, is surely the most important of the political thinkers who influenced American beliefs about government, and his most significant contributions concerned the relationship between government and natural rights, believed to be God-given rights to life, liberty, and property.
The British government had recognized its duty to protect the lives, liberties, and property of English citizens long before its North American colonies were settled, and protections for life, liberty, and property are prominent among Magna Carta's many provisions.
The rights protected by Magna Carta had been granted by the king, and, in theory, a future king or queen could take them away; the English Bill of Rights, heavily influenced by Locke's ideas, enumerated the rights of English citizens and explicitly guaranteed rights to life, liberty, and property.
In the colonists' eyes, all free White males should have the right to acquire property, and once property had been acquired, government had the duty to protect it.
Most Europeans of the time believed monarchy had been created by God and that kings and queens were divinely appointed to rule, but Locke theorized that human beings, not God, had created government.
The belief that government should not deprive people of their liberties and should be restricted in its power over citizens' lives was an important factor in the controversial decision by the American colonies to declare independence from England in 1776.
Americans were accustomed to the idea of representative government from the beginning, and the American Revolution began when American colonists felt that this longstanding tradition of representative self-government was threatened by the actions of Parliament and the King.
The American Revolution began when a small and vocal group of colonists became convinced that the king and Parliament were abusing them and depriving them of their rights.
Among the acts passed by Parliament were laws requiring colonists to pay British merchants with gold and silver instead of paper currency and a mandate that suspected smugglers be tried in vice-admiralty courts without jury trials.
Because the colonists had not consented to direct taxation, their primary objection was that it reduced their status as free men, and the right of the people or their representatives to consent to taxation was enshrined in both Magna Carta and the English Bill of Rights.
Taxes were imposed by the House of Commons, one of the two houses of the British Parliament, but the North American colonists were not allowed to elect representatives to that body, and many colonists maintained that anything except direct representation violated their rights as English subjects.
Following this event, later known as the Boston Massacre, resistance to British rule grew, especially in Massachusetts.
In the 2010s, many who did not agree with the positions of the Democratic or Republican Party organized themselves into an oppositional group dubbed the Tea Party.
In May 1775 delegates met again in the Second Continental Congress, by which time war with Great Britain had already begun following skirmishes between colonial militiamen and British troops at Lexington and Concord, Massachusetts, and Congress drafted a Declaration of Causes explaining the colonies' reasons for rebellion.
On July 2, 1776, Congress declared American independence from Britain and two days later signed the Declaration of Independence, which was drafted by Thomas Jefferson and officially proclaimed the colonies' separation from Britain.
Jefferson charged that the king had taxed the colonists without the consent of their elected representatives, interfered with their trade, denied them the right to trial by jury, and deprived them of their right to self-government.
People sacrificed a small portion of their freedom and consented to be ruled in exchange for the government’s protection of their lives, liberty, and property. Locke called this implicit agreement between a people and their government the social contract.
Should government deprive people of their rights by abusing the power given to it, the contract was broken and the people were no longer bound by its terms.
The people could thus withdraw their consent to obey and form another government for their protection.
For Locke, withdrawing consent to be ruled by an established government and forming a new one meant replacing one monarch with another.
For those colonists intent on rebelling, however, it meant establishing a new nation and creating a new government, one that would be greatly limited in the power it could exercise over the people. The desire to limit the power of government is closely related to the belief that people should govern themselves.
By 1776, they had been living under the rule of the British government for more than a century, and England had long treated the thirteen colonies with a degree of benign neglect.
Taxes imposed by England were low, and property ownership was more widespread than in England.
For the most part, American colonists were proud to be British citizens and had no desire to form an independent nation.
The outcry was so great that the new tax was quickly withdrawn, but its repeal was soon followed by a series of other tax acts, such as the Townshend Acts (1767), which imposed taxes on many everyday objects such as glass, tea, and paint.
The Massachusetts legislature sent a petition to the king asking for relief from the taxes and requested that other colonies join in a boycott of British manufactured goods.
British officials threatened to suspend the legislatures of colonies that engaged in a boycott and, in response to a request for help from Boston’s customs collector, sent a warship to the city in 1768.
In December 1773, a group of Boston men boarded a ship in Boston harbor and threw its cargo of tea, owned by the British East India Company, into the water to protest British policies, including the granting of a monopoly on tea to the British East India Company, which many colonial merchants resented.3 This act of defiance became known as the Boston Tea Party.
POLITICAL THOUGHT IN THE AMERICAN COLONIES — selected points
Magna Carta was a promise by King John and future monarchs to refrain from certain actions that harmed, or had the potential to harm, the people of England.
The rights protected by Magna Carta had been granted by the king and could in theory be taken away by a future king or queen, whereas the natural rights Locke described had been granted by God and thus could never be abolished by human beings, even royal ones, or by the institutions they created.
Before offering the throne to William and Mary, Parliament passed the English Bill of Rights in 1689, and a bill of rights is a list of the liberties and protections possessed by a nation’s citizens.
The English Bill of Rights, heavily influenced by Locke’s ideas, enumerated the rights of English citizens and explicitly guaranteed rights to life, liberty, and property, and this document would profoundly influence the U.S. Constitution and Bill of Rights.
The British government did allow for a degree of self-government: laws were made by Parliament, and property-owning males were allowed to vote for representatives to Parliament.
For instance, Virginia established its House of Burgesses in 1619, and by the eighteenth century all the colonies had established legislatures to which men were elected to make the laws for their fellow colonists.
According to Locke, anyone who invested labor in the commons—the land, forests, water, animals, and other parts of nature that were free for the taking—might take as much of these as needed, by cutting trees, for example, or building a fence around a field.
The only restriction was that no one could take so much that others were deprived of their right to take from the commons as well.
THE AMERICAN REVOLUTION — selected points
All this began to change in 1763 when the Seven Years War between Great Britain and France came to an end and Great Britain gained control of most of the French territory in North America.
The colonists had fought on behalf of Britain, and many colonists expected that after the war they would be allowed to settle on land west of the Appalachian Mountains that had been taken from France, but their hopes were not realized.
Hoping to prevent conflict with Indian tribes in the Ohio Valley, Parliament passed the Proclamation of 1763, which forbade the colonists to purchase land or settle west of the Appalachian Mountains.
To pay its debts from the war and maintain the troops it left behind to protect the colonies, the British government had to take new measures to raise revenue.
What angered the colonists most of all, however, was the imposition of direct taxes: taxes imposed on individuals instead of on transactions.
A few months later, British troops arrived, and on the evening of March 5, 1770, an altercation erupted outside the customs house; shots rang out as the soldiers fired into the crowd, several people were hit, and three died immediately.
The king had “establish[ed] . . . an absolute Tyranny over these States.”
Just as their English forebears had removed King James II from the throne in 1689, the colonists now wished to establish a new rule.
Jefferson then proceeded to list the many ways in which the British monarch had abused his power and failed in his duties to his subjects, and such intrusions on their rights could not be tolerated; with their signing of the Declaration of Independence, the founders of the United States committed themselves to the creation of a new kind of government.
In the early months of 1774, Parliament responded to this latest act of colonial defiance by passing a series of laws called the Coercive Acts, intended to punish Boston for leading resistance to British rule and to restore order in the colonies.
These acts virtually abolished town meetings in Massachusetts and otherwise interfered with the colony’s ability to govern itself.
This assault on Massachusetts and its economy enraged people throughout the colonies, and delegates from all the colonies except Georgia formed the First Continental Congress to create a unified opposition to Great Britain. Among other things, members of the institution developed a declaration of rights and grievances.
Quiz (8 questions)
Which term matches this description: “a promise by King John to his subjects that he and future monarchs would refrain from certain actions that harmed, or had the potential to harm, the people of England”?
- Magna Carta
- Bill of rights
- Mayflower Compact
- Proclamation of 1763
Show the answer
Magna Carta. Magna Carta was the promise King John signed in 1215 that he and future monarchs would refrain from certain actions that harmed, or could harm, the people of England. A bill of rights is a list of the liberties and protections possessed by a nation's citizens. The Mayflower Compact was an agreement by the Pilgrims to govern themselves by laws made by the colony's male voters. The Proclamation of 1763 forbade colonists to purchase land or settle west of the Appalachian Mountains.
Which term is defined as “a list of the liberties and protections possessed by a nation's citizens”?
- Boston tea Party
- Bill of rights
- Proclamation of 1763
- Magna Carta
Show the answer
Bill of rights. A bill of rights is a list of the liberties and protections possessed by a nation's citizens, and the English Bill of Rights enumerated such rights and guaranteed life, liberty, and property. The Boston Tea Party was a protest in which colonists threw tea into Boston harbor. Magna Carta was King John's promise to refrain from certain harmful actions against the people of England. The Proclamation of 1763 forbade colonists to purchase land or settle west of the Appalachian Mountains.
Which term matches this description: “an agreement to govern themselves according to the laws created by the male voters of the colony”?
- Commons
- Proclamation of 1763
- Mayflower Compact
- Social contract
Show the answer
Mayflower Compact. The Mayflower Compact was the Pilgrims' agreement to govern themselves according to laws created by the male voters of the colony. The commons are the land, forests, water, animals, and other parts of nature free for the taking. The Proclamation of 1763 forbade colonists to purchase land or settle west of the Appalachian Mountains. The social contract is Locke's idea of an implicit agreement between a people and their government.
True or false: The American Revolution began when colonists felt their tradition of representative self-government was threatened by Parliament and the King.
- True
- False
Show the answer
True. The American Revolution began when colonists felt their longstanding tradition of representative self-government was threatened by the actions of Parliament and the King. That tradition included elected colonial legislatures and, earlier, the Mayflower Compact, under which the Pilgrims governed themselves by laws made by the colony's male voters.
True or false: Magna Carta's provisions prominently include protections for life, liberty, and property.
- True
- False
Show the answer
True. Magna Carta, the promise King John signed in 1215, prominently includes protections for life, liberty, and property among its many provisions. One of its clauses lays the foundation for the Fifth and Sixth Amendments, and by the American Revolution English subjects regarded it as a cornerstone of liberty for men of all stations.
True or false: The British government recognized its duty to protect the lives, liberties, and property of English citizens long before the settling of its North American colonies.
- True
- False
Show the answer
True. The British government had recognized its duty to protect the lives, liberties, and property of English citizens long before its North American colonies were settled. Magna Carta, signed by King John in 1215, is an early expression of that duty, and its protections for life, liberty, and property are prominent among its provisions.
Which statement defines “commons”?
- a tax requiring that almost all paper goods, such as diplomas, land deeds, contracts, and newspapers, have revenue stamps placed on them
- a promise by King John to his subjects that he and future monarchs would refrain from certain actions that harmed, or had the potential to harm, the people of England
- the land, forests, water, animals, and other parts of nature that were free for the taking
- a list of the liberties and protections possessed by a nation's citizens
Show the answer
the land, forests, water, animals, and other parts of nature that were free for the taking. The commons are the land, forests, water, animals, and other parts of nature that were free for the taking, and labor invested in them justified taking what was needed, limited only by others' right to take as well. The description of paper goods needing revenue stamps defines the Stamp Act. The promise by King John to refrain from certain harmful actions defines Magna Carta. A list of the liberties and protections possessed by a nation's citizens defines a bill of rights.
Which statement defines “social contract”?
- a measure that forbade the colonists to purchase land or settle west of the Appalachian Mountains
- the land, forests, water, animals, and other parts of nature that were free for the taking
- the implicit agreement between a people and their government
- an agreement to govern themselves according to the laws created by the male voters of the colony
Show the answer
the implicit agreement between a people and their government. The social contract is the implicit agreement between a people and their government, in which people consent to be ruled in exchange for protection of their lives, liberty, and property. The measure forbidding colonists to purchase land or settle west of the Appalachian Mountains is the Proclamation of 1763. The land, forests, water, animals, and other parts of nature free for the taking are the commons. The agreement to govern by laws created by the colony's male voters is the Mayflower Compact.


